Medicare Advantage · 2027 Star Ratings · October 2026
The 2027 Star Ratings show more plans losing a large share of their members again. Here is what the new CMS numbers say, how the measure works, and what plans can do while this year's enrollment period is open.
For Medicare Advantage leaders in Stars, growth and member experience · 4-minute read
How many members leave a typical Medicare Advantage plan? In the 2027 Star Ratings, the middle contract had 14% of members choose to leave. CMS gives 5 stars when 8% or fewer leave, and 1 star when more than 37% leave.
What the 2027 Star Ratings show
CMS scores every Medicare Advantage contract on "Members Choosing to Leave the Plan." The 2027 Star Ratings count members who chose to leave during 2025.
38% of contracts lost 20% or more of their members. That is up from 32% a year earlier, and back to where it was in the 2024 Star Ratings. [Calculated]
The typical contract lost 14% of its members. That is the median of 517 contracts with a score, the same as last year. The middle half of contracts lost between 6.5% and 25%. [Calculated]
More contracts got better than worse, but not by much. Of 468 contracts scored both years, 48% lost fewer members and 39% lost more. [Calculated]
One in six contracts earned only 1 or 2 stars on this measure (89 of 517). One in three earned 5 stars (170). [Calculated]
How the measure works
To earn 5 stars, 8% or fewer of members can choose to leave. 4 stars allows up to 17%. Above 37%, a contract gets 1 star. These cut points changed little from last year. [Sourced: CMS]
It counts choices, not moves. CMS removes members who moved out of the service area, lost their plan when it closed, or were in an employer group plan. What is left is members who could have stayed and did not. [Sourced: CMS]
It carries a weight of 2 in the Part C rating, down from 4 in the 2025 Star Ratings. It also feeds the health plan quality improvement measure. [Sourced: CMS]
The bigger cost is not the star. Every member who leaves takes their revenue with them, and has to be replaced by winning a new member.
Why members leave
CMS also asks members who leave a plan why they left. The October 8 data tables for 2027 do not include that reasons table, so the latest reasons are from the 2026 Star Ratings. In that data, three reasons stand out:
Coverage of doctors and hospitals is the most common reason at plans that lose the most members.
Financial reasons lead at plans that keep most of their members.
Information and help from the plan grows as plans lose more members.
We broke this down by plan in Three disenrollment tiers in Medicare Advantage.
Member retention strategies plans can use now
A plan cannot text its way out of a narrow network or a high premium. But the third reason, getting information and help, is in the plan's own hands. Six moves, starting before the enrollment period closes on December 7:
Find who is struggling. Members with open care gaps, late refills or recent complaints are telling you something. Rank them and reach them first.
Make help easy to get. Answer benefit questions, including supplemental benefits and how much a member has used, without a phone call.
Reach members in their own language. A secure text a member can open and answer right away is easier to act on than a letter in the mail.
Warn members before a network change hits. Coverage of doctors and hospitals is the top reason members leave plans that lose the most. Tell members early when a doctor or hospital leaves the network, and help them find one that is still in it.
Explain costs in plain words. Financial reasons lead at plans that keep most members. Show members what they will pay, and point those who qualify to Medicare’s Extra Help with drug costs.
Check in with new members early. Make sure each new member has found a doctor and filled their medicines in their first few months.
Where Marples fits
Marples finds each member's open care gaps using NCQA HEDIS standards and ranks the members to reach first. Members get secure texts in their preferred language. They can request refills and check their benefits by text. Your care management team reviews any message with clinical details before it goes out. See how Marples works for health plans.
How we counted: Carelytics calculated every [Calculated] figure from the CMS Star Ratings Measure Data tables for 2024 to 2027, Part C measure "Members Choosing to Leave the Plan." Contracts without a score are left out. Figures count contracts, not members. Sources: CMS 2027 Star Ratings data tables; CMS 2027 Star Ratings Technical Notes.

